Birds-Eye.Net
All things broadband and more...
 
Web Birds-Eye.Net
What's New?

Download Purchased Items

Research:
Analysis
International

Reference:
Acronyms & Definitions
Articles
Broadband Directory
Legacy
Operations
Technical
Yearly Predictions
> RSS Feeds <

Business Forms:
Due Diligence Checklist
Funding & VC Due Diligence
Real Estate Due Diligence

Resources:
Monitoring/Reporting/Benchmarking
Patent Harvesting Kit
Ready to Use Scripts
Source Code

Referral:
Expert Consulting
Referral

Other:
Advertise With Us
Feedback
Recommended Reading
Fishing
House
Baby in the City
Blog

Featured Product:

Service Qualification Software Market Research
[Back to Birds-Eye.Net Market Research]

By: Bruce Bahlmann - Contributing Author (your feedback is important to us!)

Update: December 21, 2005
Created:
September 28, 2002

Document:

According to Yankee Group forecasts, broadband data service in the US is growing at that rate of about 5 million subscribers per year. Average churn among broadband data providers is about two percent which results in an additional ~614k subscribers changing providers. As a result there is an opportunity to sell 5.614 million units of service qualification software within the US alone annually – at least through the year 2007. The current (2002) 19 million broadband users in the US represent roughly 6 percent of the US population and the 5-year projection is that up to 17% of the US population will have broadband subscriptions by the year 2007. If the US population represents 4% of the world population, the global annual market for service qualification software is approximately 126 million units – assuming the penetration and adoption rates worldwide resemble that of the US. Of course these assumptions are not the case so this figure is a best-case scenario. 

Service qualification software vendors receive anywhere from $0.50 to $1.50 per unit for their software. If we average this cost over all units sold the average costs of service qualification software is probably around $1 US per unit or less. So the worldwide market for service qualification software is around $126 million annually. How this revenue is divided up among vendors depends on the number of operators each vendor has sold to.

Company Info

Founded Public/Private Relative Market Share Share of $126 million annually Employees
Aramova
524A Union Street
San Francisco, CA 94133
Tel: 415.242.1984
1995 Private 7 (?) of

9.2%

~$11 million 21
Friendly Technologies
94-01 68th Ave.
Forest Hills, NY 11375
Tel: 866.447.8640
1997 Private 17 (200+) of

22%

~$28 million 16
Fine Point Technologies
90 John Street
New York, NY 10038
Tel: 212.962.7410
1997 Private 4 (400) of

5.2%

~$6 million 20
Motive
12515 Research Blvd.
Building 5
Austin, Texas 78759
Tel: 512.339.8335
1997 Private 25 (?) of

32%

~$41 million 230
NetSurfer
150 Interstate North Parkway
Suite 220
Atlanta, GA 30339
Tel: 770.956.7873
1994 Private 1? (500) of

1%

$1 million ?
SupportSoft
575 Broadway
Redwood City, California 94063
Tel: 650.556.9440
1994 Private 22 (250) of

29%

~$36 million ?

Table 1.0 Company and Associated Market Share Summary Information

In Table 1.0, the relative market share represents an approximation of the number of broadband service providers that have signed up with a particular service qualification software vendor. The actual share of the $126 million received by each vendor is dependent not only on the number of service providers each vendor signs up but also how many subscribers each of those vendors support. Since this information is not really available these numbers are only approximate. Note that a number of broadband service providers may use multiple service qualification vendors so a vendor may not be able to claim all of the broadband service provider subscriber numbers.

Invenstor, customer and product info:

Company Investors Past/Present Customer Wins Product(s)
Aramova ? AT&T, Bell Canada, MindSpring, NTL (UK), Telewest (UK), Verizon, XO Communications Gearbox
Friendly Technologies Vectory Investment Company, Linktech and Argoquest Inc.- and by its founders, Mr. Elan Migdal and Mr. Yuval Matron. Alvarion, Bezeq, Broadwing, Cingular, Excel, Fidelity Networks, Flash Networks, IBM, IP Applications, NetVision, Redback Networks, Startnet, Sprint, TisCali, US Lec, Wanado FriendlySI, FriendlyPPPoE, GoBroadband, BroadbandReady
Fine Point Technologies ? Claims to have 400 some customers CyberTruck, ServPoET, WinPoET, TotalInternet
Motive ? Adelphia, Aliant Telecom, AT&T Broadband, Bell Canada, Bell South, Charter Communications, NTL, RoadRunner, SBC Communications, Sprint, TELMEX, TELUS, Time Warner Cable ControlWorks
NetSurfer ? Nearly 500 internet access providers, sold over 4 million licenses in 14 different countries NetKit
SupportSoft ? 3M, Adelphia, ADP, Assurant Solutions, Bank of America, Bell South, BT, Charter, Cisco, Comcast, CompuCom, Cox, ibm, kpn, Procter&Gamble, Siebel, Sony Real-Time Service Management (RTSM), Endpoint Automation Suite, Assisted Service Suite, Self-Service Suite

Table 2.0 Investor, Customer, and Product Info

Interesting Links to Vendor White Papers:

ServiceWare - White Papers

Technical feature comparison of service qualification companies:

The following is a list of possible service qualification features as well as those that have been publically claimed (through websites, press releases, etc.) by the vendors below. This analysis merely represents a survey of possible features supported by different vendors - actual features that exist on shipping products by these vendors may vary.

Company/Features Aramova Friendly Technologies Fine Point Technologies Motive NetSurfer SupportSoft
Standard/Platform Features (6 items)
Administration kit X O X O O X
Driver installation X X X X X X
Software installation X X X X X X
Software configuration X X X X X X
Optional client software/hardware inventory X O X O X X
Update Engine (branding, config, etc.) X X X O O X
Broadband (34 items)
Cable - HSD support X X X X X X
Telco - DSL support X X X X X X
Apple, unix, windows support Apple, windows Windows Apple, windows Apple, windows Windows/unix Apple, windows
Languages supported English, German, French, Italian English English, Dutch, Korean, Spanish, Japanese, Portuguese, and 8 others English English, Japanese, Portuguese, Spanish English, German, French, Italian
OSS component X - partner O X X X X - partner
Auto NIC & TCP/IP detection X X X X X X
Bandwidth QoS measurements X X X O X X
Client

CD client

X X X X X X

Download client

X X X O X X

Regional CD client

X O O X X X
Dial-Roaming Support

Optional auto LAN/dialup selection

O O O O X O

Alternate for mobile users

X O O O X X

Backup for outage

X O O O X X
Dynamic service selection O O X O O O
HTML dashboard (before, after install) X - both O O O O X - both
Integrated 3rd party software installation X O O X X X
Messaging to clients O O X O O O
Multiple ISP X X O X X X

Conversions

X O O X O X
Optional forced login to network O O O O X O

Detailed connection tracing

O X X O O O

Pay-per-use application support

O X O O O O

PPPoE client (multi-session)

X X X O O X

PPPoE Server

O O X O O O

PPTP client (single session)

O X O O O O

Remote control & management

O X X O O O

Sessioning application options

O X X O O O
Optional vendor specific modem detection and diagnostic X O O O X X
Optional vendor specific NIC/driver installation X O O O X X
Pre-install detection of min. requirements X X X X X X
Post-install service checks X O X O O X
Portal direct O O X O O O
Residential gateway O X O X O O
Self-healing diagnostics X X X O O X
Self-installation X X X X X X
Service initiation X X X X O X
Support automation (self-care) X X X X X X
WatchDog O O X O O O
Dialup (10 items)
Apple, unix, windows support Apple, windows Apple, windows Apple, windows O windows/unix Apple, windows
Connectivity QoS measurements O X O O X O
Customizable dialers O X O O O O
Demographic information collector O O O O X O
Dynamic re-branding X O O O X X
Internet desktop application X X O O X X
Online registration X X X O X X
Pre-install detection of min. requirements X X X O X X
Support automation X X X O X X
Targeted content distribution X O O O X X
Wireless (4 items)
GPRS support O X ? O O O
GSM support O X ? O O O
HSCSD support O X ? O O O
Support automation O X ? O O O
Satellite (1 items)
? O O ? O O O
Results:
SCORE (out of 59 possible categories) 36 35 35 17.5 33.5 36
Percentage of possible 61.08% 59.3% 59.5% 29.7% 56.8% 61.08%
RATING excellent excellent excellent poor excellent excellent

Index:
X = Supported
O = Not Supported
? = Partially, not fully, or questionably supported

Technical feature discrepancies:

Companies Aramova Motive Friendly Technologies Fine Point Technologies NetSurfer SupportSoft
Unique or specialized capabilities HTML content driven pre/post install. Unique regional CD and residential gateway support. Unique Quality of Service management capabilities for multiple services Unique PPPoE client/server architecture Unix support and optional forced login to network feature. Unix support and optional forced login to network feature.
Strong points Remote configuration, software, and branding management.  Flexible integration with 3rd parties. Understanding of broadband space (especially cable  where a majority of its customers come from). Supports multiple clients over multiple service configurations Premiere PPPoE provider. Has end to end solution including clients and servers. Best overall support for dialup capability. Best overall support for dialup capability.
Weak points Limited dial-roaming support. Lack of multi-market capability. Lack of muti-market capability. Lacks sessioning capabilities to support PPPoE and PPTP. Administrative capabilities also lacking. Lack of support for Apple, no administration tools, no dial-roaming support. Limited dial-roaming support. Does not seem to have ways to collect demographic information. Lack of support for Apple. Limited multi-market capability. Lack of support for Apple. Limited multi-market capability.
Question marks? What is this software's sessioning capabilities? How many languages does this software support? How is this software remotely managed - if at all? How easily can these applications be configured or customized for each operator or reseller? How well and to what extent does it support NON-PPPoE operating customers. How much emphasis is this company placing on PPPoE and what other uses are their for their server software besides supporting PPPoE? How well are the broadband capabilities integrated into those of its dialup client (broadband client appears weakest of two)? How well are the broadband capabilities integrated into those of its dialup client (broadband client appears weakest of two)?
General thoughts on company direction Seems to have pretty good success selling on its own as well through its  partners. The capability and flexibility of this tool provide for a wealth of options for 3rd parties. Seem to be focused on broadband-cable and increasingly understanding DSL. The approach of focusing on increasingly more markets addressing each market's needs and then moving on as market share increases seems to be working - thus confirming that product reflects the needs of market. Seem to be approaching all markets - broadcast mode but with respect to their offering to any particular market their product lacks focus. Seems to be approaching all markets in a kind of broadcast marketing approach. However, unlike Friendly, this approach seems centered around offering PPPoE solution that is offered in an end-to-end variety. Perhaps the market leader in sales wins but is the technology lager. Seems to be pushing vendor specific capabilities to boost partnerships and distribution channels. Perhaps the market leader in sales wins but is the technology lager. Seems to be pushing vendor specific capabilities to boost partnerships and distribution channels.
Possible roadblocks that lie ahead Lack of multi-market capability could jeopardize partnerships if solution fails to deliver working products in these areas. Administrative tools must evolve in concert with overall capability of software. May be difficult to sustain this feature set over multiple services and markets. The lack of product completeness to address the needs of its focused customer base prevents this product from securely winning its customers. As a result customer base will erode as better technology competes. Many of its current customers have multiple deals with its competitors. With focus lacking, the product begs a best in class capability. QoS and wireless support could be that differentiate. However, the wireless market is small and evolving and QoS has yet to secure a strong hold of importance. Could be a while before these capabilities get serious attention from potential customers. PPPoE is in many ways superior to traditional cable-HSD services that offer general TCP/IP connections. However this change requires something slightly different of an experience by the customer. As a result this approach is best in greenfield installations but not so easy to deploy over incumbent TCP/IP connection services. Lack of management, development, and customization  tools will limit the success of the above strategy. May be struggling with the need to retool software to adopt more current array of features offered by competitors - vendor customizations may just be a short term strategy to boost sales channels during transition. Lack of management, development, and customization  tools will limit the success of the above strategy. May be struggling with the need to retool software to adopt more current array of features offered by competitors - vendor customizations may just be a short term strategy to boost sales channels during transition.

External factors that could reshuffle leadership among vendors in this space:

Technology Event Relative chance of occurring
PPPoE Widespread adoption of PPPoE would elevate those vendors that currently support this capability to elite status. 30%
     

General questions I have for this industry are:

What happens after the gold rush? Once a majority of people have signed up for broadband what happens next? Service qualification vendors need to begin thinking of their second life after the gold rush where a majority of their income will not come from signing up broadband subscribers but from some other source. What will that source be?

Readers who use this information for investment purposes do so at their own risk! Opinions expressed are just that and not based on insider information or information otherwise obtained illegally.

Can Birds-Eye.Net help you or your Company?
Receive your Birds-Eye.Net articles and white papers hot off the presses by adding our RSS feed to your reader.

 

 

(C) Copyright Birds-Eye.Net, All rights reserved.
It is against the law to reproduce this content or any portion of it in any form without the explicit written permission of Birds-Eye Network Services, LLC. Federal copyright law (17 USC 504) makes it illegal, punishable with fines up to $100,000 per violation plus attorney's fees.